Lila's bookshelf: currently-reading

Divine Secrets of the Ya-Ya SisterhoodEnder's GameFahrenheit 451Brave New World1984Outlander

More of Lila's books »
Lila Garlinghouse's currently-reading book recommendations, reviews, favorite quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists

Saturday, October 9, 2010

From Progress to Digress

This week in English, we spent a lot of time focusing on ancient Greek philosphers. So far, we've read two of Plato's dialogues which revolve around Socrates. The first was The Apology and the second was Crito. The Apology was Socrates' defense statement that he made to the jury of Athens while he was on trial for corrupting the youth and going against the Greek Gods. I thought that the concept of someone being on trial for corrupting the youth was almost humorous. With all of the "corrupting" influences that we have in today's society that are aimed directly at young people, it's amazing that such a thing could have ever been considered criminal. Billions of dollars are spent on marketing teams who are paid to find out exactly what it is that young people want and how to convince them that their lives are inadequate without the selling product. If the Athenian jury were to see American society today, I'm sure that the verdict would be Hemlock for everyone. However, when California was in such a heated state over Prop 8, many supporters argued that teaching the possibility of homosexual marriage in classrooms would be unacceptable and would give young children the wrong idea. It seems to me that as seemingly far as society comes, the more similar it seems.

1 comment:

  1. I really like the connections you've made between the past and the present. I actually hadn't really even thought about that until now, and you're right about all of it. I think it's also pretty interesting to think that if Socrates lived in our time, he would probably just be treated as a crazy-hippie-activist type (like those annoying GreenPeace people who stand outside of Trader Joe's) instead of a hero.

    -Rachel DeNoble (:

    ReplyDelete